data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/462eb/462eb2eff2974d3367e66228141f8d0e62dd2217" alt="Smiley"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/20fb4/20fb4845a2d38f16f52d717eb642e9c68b8ab0e9" alt="Smiley"
It seems the show has reached the end of the line, and with the Judges disappearing one by one, its only dying a slow, painful death.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3152c/3152c36aa55f4c7c5081abb839f5d1b191e2580e" alt="Smiley"
My personal opinion, in order to save whatever dignity the show has left, they should start over fresh. Go back to the 3-panel style of judging and stick to a formula that works. Look at America's Got Talent. It’s stayed popular for so long because it sticks to a formula that works, and the changes that are made to the show (example: a replacement judge) are ones that work and don't disrupt the perfect formula.
As far as choosing one of the new judges, I nominate Steve Tyler. He'd be the perfect replacement for Paula Abdul, for a number of obvious reasons
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/51880/518800d088db6952f8a7cc1813df834d3e46454c" alt="Smiley"
What do you think of the new judges? Comment about it!